Reviewers Reviewed

For the weekend of October 13:

Critic Review Quote Analysis This Week's Verdict
Manohla Dargis,
The New York Times
Elizabeth: The Golden Age "A kitsch extravaganza aquiver with trembling bosoms, booming guns and wild energy, Elizabeth: The Golden Age tells, if more often shouts, the story of the bastard monarch who ruled England with an iron grip and two tightly closed legs. " Trembling bosoms and booming guns. . . Oh my. Other choice quotes: "favorite smoldering slab of man meat," and "she found sweet relief by violently bringing the Spanish Empire to its knees." Is it getting hot in here?
Stephanie Zacharek,
Salon.com
Elizabeth: The Golden Age "She giggles and titters with her favorite lady-in-waiting, Bess (played by the luminous Abby Cornish) — the two have a relationship that's semi-erotic and semiotic, a language of signals and half-smiles that's largely, though not wholly, innocent." A relationship that's semi-erotic and semiotic? Sounds like freshman year to me.

JArmond White,
New York Press
Elizabeth: The Golden Age "The Golden Age is another unwarranted film, adding to the atrocious 1998 Elizabeth where Cate Blanchett played the Plantagenet royal in ludicrously modern style. Blanchett has become the reigning character assassin of contemporary movies. She's an Aussie pretender to the throne of British acting and only gullible Anglophiles will accept her affectations." When it isn't hipster filmmakers or insipid sequels it's Aussie pretenders. What isn't wrong with filmmaking today?
Michelle Orange,
The Village Voice
The Heartbreak Kid "Leaving the Jew/Shiksa conundrum of the original behind, here Stiller's Eddie Cantor marries the marquee goddess after a brief courtship, only to find she's a bit of a mess in the fine print. On their disastrous Mexican honeymoon, he meets salt-of-the-earth southerner Miranda (Michelle Monaghan), clearly a superior option because — like Diaz in Mary — she likes sports, cracks jokes, and presumably lacks his wife's unseemly sex drive." In one paragraph: A comprehensive yet subtle analysis of what's wrong with most Ben Stiller movies.
Chris Lee,
L.A. Times
Across the Universe "After three weeks in theaters, the PG-13 movie finally penetrated the top ten by connecting with a zealous core constituency: teenage girls, who, anecdotal evidence suggests, are going to see the movie in packs, bonding with one another (and the film) through repeated viewings and popularizing it with their school chums via word-of-mouth." A day late and a dollar short. But yes; if Across The Universe has any relevance that's it. Teenage girls. God. What is wrong with teenage girls? Wasn't there a time when Courtney Love was a role model?

Sarah Sundberg



Previous Weeks:
Weekend of December 15, 2007
Weekend of December 01, 2007
Weekend of November 17, 2007
Weekend of November 10, 2007
Weekend of November 3, 2007
Weekend of October 26, 2007
Weekend of October 20, 2007
Weekend of October 13, 2007
Weekend of October 6, 2007
Weekend of September 29, 2007
Weekend of September 22, 2007
Weekend of September 15, 2007
Weekend of September 8, 2007
Weekend of September 1, 2007
Weekend of August 25, 2007
Weekend of August 18, 2007
Weekend of August 11, 2007
Weekend of August 4, 2007
Weekend of July 27, 2007
Weekend of July 21, 2007
Weekend of July 14, 2007
Weekend of July 7, 2007
Weekend of June 30, 2007
Weekend of June 23, 2007
Weekend of June 16, 2007
Weekend of June 9, 2007
Weekend of June 2, 2007
Weekend of May 26, 2007
Weekend of May 19, 2007
Weekend of May 12, 2007
Weekend of May 05, 2007
Weekend of April 28, 2007
Weekend of April 21, 2007
Weekend of April 14, 2007
Weekend of April 7, 2007
Weekend of March 31, 2007
Weekend of March 24, 2007
Weekend of March 17, 2007
Weekend of March 10, 2007
Weekend of March 3, 2007
Weekend of February 16, 2007
Weekend of February 9, 2007
Weekend of January 20, 2007
Weekend of January 6, 2007
Weekend of December 15, 2006
Weekend of December 8, 2006
Weekend of December 1, 2006
Weekend of November 10, 2006
Weekend of November 3, 2006
Weekend of October 27, 2006
Weekend of October 20, 2006
Weekend of October 13, 2006
Weekend of October 6, 2006
Weekend of September 29, 2006
Weekend of September 22, 2006
Weekend of September 15, 2006
Weekend of September 8, 2006
Weekend of September 1, 2006
Weekend of August 25, 2006
Weekend of August 18, 2006
Weekend of August 11, 2006
Weekend of August 4, 2006



NEW THIS WEEK

READER RATINGS

more new films >    

FUNNIEST FILMS

READER RATINGS

more funny films >    

PERSONAL OF THE DAY

 

SMARTEST FILMS

READER RATINGS

more smart films >    

SEXIEST FILMS

READER RATINGS

more sexy films >